Looking twice at the history of science

Wednesday, September 16, 2015

Scientists and the symmetry principle: an email exchange with Steven Weinberg

Earlier this week I received an email from Steven Weinberg, the physicist whose book To Explain the World was critically reviewed by Steven Shapin earlier this year. I commented on Shapin’s review in this essay, and in the process I attributed errors to Weinberg that he disclaimed in his email. Weinberg asked that I publish his email, and my reply, on this blog. I was happy to oblige. As I point out in my reply, Weinberg’s reaction to my essay is an additional reason to adopt the symmetry principle that I defended in earlier posts. Expand post.


  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

  2. Sign up for email newsletters from the top companies and view the way they use personalization, economy of language, colorful description and more to make a sale with their bulk email marketing campaigns. how to send bulk email using gmail

  3. Marketers considering taking part in email marketing to advance their image and business products today ought to consider executing consent based email marketing. US Email Lists 2018

  4. Much obliged you all that much to share these connections. Will look at this.. hotmail email login

  5. I feel like people already know this, but if you verify email address from your list, you will have lower bounce rates and better results from your email campaigns.